Choosing a Roofer for Your Church: A Committee's Bid Checklist
A step-by-step checklist for church building committees in Tulsa: writing the scope, comparing bids, checking contractors and what to put in the contract.

The short answer: Start with a written, photographed roof assessment, then give every bidder the same written scope. Get about three bids, walk the roof with each bidder, and compare them on a simple scoresheet covering scope, materials, price, warranty, schedule, insurance and references. Check licenses and insurance, call references, and put the scope, payment schedule, warranty and cleanup terms in the contract.
In this guide 13 sections
- Step 1: Get a Written Assessment First
- Step 2: Write One Scope for Everyone
- Step 3: Choose Who to Invite
- Step 4: Walk the Roof With Each Bidder
- Step 5: Compare Bids Side by Side
- Questions to Ask Every Bidder
- Check the Contractor Before You Choose
- What to Put in the Contract
- Red Flags
- Running the Process as a Committee
- Frequently Asked Questions About Choosing a Church Roofer
- Get a Bid for Your Church Roof
- Related Reading
Choosing a roofer is one of the biggest decisions a church building committee will make. The contract is large, the roof will be there for decades, and the people making the choice are volunteers who may never have bought a roof before. A clear process protects the church, and a poor one can lead to surprises in the middle of the project.
This guide is a working checklist for trustees, deacons, building committees and pastors in the Tulsa area. It covers how to write the scope, how to collect bids that can be compared, what to ask, how to check a contractor, and what to put in the contract. For the funding side, see how churches pay for a new roof, and for the technical side see church roofing services in Tulsa.
Step 1: Get a Written Assessment First
Before you ask for bids, find out what the roof actually needs. A written assessment with photos should tell you the age and condition of each section, what's causing the leaks, and what options make sense. Without it, every bidder will price something different, and you won't be able to tell which bid is right. Our commercial roof inspection checklist shows what a good assessment covers.
Step 2: Write One Scope for Everyone
Give every bidder the same description of the work so the prices are for the same job. Include:
- Which roof sections are included, with a simple drawing or photos
- The roof system you want, or a request for options with prices
- What happens to the old roof, including tear-off or overlay
- Decking, insulation and flashing, and how hidden damage will be priced
- Steeples, gutters, downspouts, vents and rooftop equipment
- Cleanup, protection of landscaping and the parking lot
- Schedule limits, such as work that can't happen during services, weddings or funerals
- Required warranty, insurance and documentation
Step 3: Choose Who to Invite
Three bids is a good number for most projects. Look for contractors who:
- Have done church or other large occupied commercial roofs, and will give references
- Are properly licensed and insured. See our guide to Oklahoma roofer license requirements.
- Are certified by the manufacturer of the system you're considering, so the warranty is valid
- Have a local office and a history in the area, so they're available for service later
If a member of the congregation has a roofing business, include them in the same process as everyone else and have them disclose the connection. That protects them and the church.
Step 4: Walk the Roof With Each Bidder
Schedule a site visit with every bidder, ideally on the same terms. Have someone from the committee attend each one. Pay attention to how they inspect, what they notice and the questions they ask. A bidder who never goes on the roof can't price it properly. Take notes so you can compare what each said.
Step 5: Compare Bids Side by Side
Use a simple scoresheet so the committee evaluates every bid the same way. A one-page comparison like this works:
| What to compare | What to look for |
|---|---|
| Scope | Same sections, same system, same extras. Anything missing should be flagged. |
| System and materials | Named products and manufacturers, not just "shingles" or "membrane" |
| Price | Itemized by section, with allowances for decking and hidden damage clearly stated |
| Warranty | Manufacturer warranty and workmanship warranty, with years, coverage and what voids it |
| Schedule | Start date, duration and how services and events are handled |
| Insurance and license | Current certificates that name the church, and valid registration |
| References | Similar jobs you can visit or call about |
| Communication | Who your single contact is and how quickly they respond |
Our guide to reading a roofing estimate explains the line items. Don't automatically pick the lowest number. Find out why bids differ, since the difference is often in the scope.
Questions to Ask Every Bidder
- What system do you recommend for each section, and why?
- How will you handle the steeple, valleys, flashing and any unusual details?
- What manufacturer warranty comes with this work, and what do you need to do to keep it valid?
- What does your workmanship warranty cover, and for how long?
- What happens if you find rotted decking or wet insulation after tear-off, and how is that priced?
- How will you protect the building, landscaping and parking lot?
- How will you work around services and church events?
- Who will supervise the job on site every day?
- How will you document the work with photos?
- Can we talk to the last three churches or commercial customers you worked for?
Check the Contractor Before You Choose
- Confirm the registration and license are current.
- Ask for certificates of insurance directly from the insurer, including general liability and workers' compensation.
- Call the references and ask about communication, schedule, cleanup and how problems were handled.
- Look at completed work, and visit a job in progress if possible.
- Check reviews and the company's history in the area.
What to Put in the Contract
- The full scope, system, materials and sections covered
- Price, payment schedule and how change orders are priced and approved. Avoid large payments up front, and tie payments to progress.
- Start and completion dates, and how weather delays are handled
- Warranty documents, with the church named as the owner
- Insurance requirements and proof of coverage
- Cleanup and protection requirements
- Lien waivers from the contractor and major suppliers as payments are made
- A process for resolving problems
Have the church's attorney or an experienced member review the contract. Our roofing contract checklist covers what to get in writing.
Red Flags
- Pressure to sign quickly or a price that's only good today
- A bid without a written scope or named materials
- A contractor who knocks on the door after a storm. See storm chaser red flags.
- No local address, no references or reluctance to show insurance
- A request for a large payment before any work begins
- A price far below the others that doesn't explain why
Running the Process as a Committee
- Name one person as the contact for bidders, so everyone gets the same information.
- Keep notes and the scoresheet, so the decision is easy to explain to the congregation.
- Share a summary with the board and, if required, the congregation before signing.
- Keep records of the bids, the decision and the contract in the church's files.
Frequently Asked Questions About Choosing a Church Roofer
How many bids should a church get?
Three is a good target for most projects. It's enough to see the range without making the process too heavy for volunteers.
Should the church take the lowest bid?
Not automatically. Compare the scope, materials, warranty and references first. A lower price that leaves out decking, flashing or cleanup can end up costing more.
Can a church member's company bid on the roof?
Yes, if the church wants. Put them through the same process, have them disclose the relationship, and keep the evaluation documented.
What warranty should a church roof have?
Ask for both a manufacturer warranty on the roofing system and a workmanship warranty from the installer. Get the terms in writing, including what voids them.
How do we schedule around services?
Put it in the scope. Ask the contractor how they'll phase the work and what happens on service days, weddings and funerals, and include it in the contract.
Get a Bid for Your Church Roof
We'll walk the roofs with your committee, photograph what we find and give you a written scope, a detailed price for each section and a schedule built around your calendar. Request a free church roof assessment. No pressure, just clear information for your committee.
Related Reading
- Church Roofing Services in Tulsa
- How Churches Pay for a New Roof
- School Roofing in Tulsa
- How to Read a Roofing Estimate
Schedule Your Free Roof Assessment →
Sources and disclaimer. Information in this article comes from manufacturer documentation, industry standards and RainTech’s own commercial roofing experience. It was current as of November 19, 2026; laws, insurance rules, manufacturer terms and prices change. This article is general information, not legal, insurance, tax or financial advice.


